The Evidence from Lucidia by Garland of Hours
This is a cover of a song by the Baltimore band Lungfish.
Garland of Hours formed in 2000 when Amy Domingues began performing her keyboard and cello-based songs with a rotating cast of friends, including Brendan Canty, Jerry Busher, Brandon Butler, and Mary Timony. Her self-titled debut appeared not long after, and an appearance in the DC music documentary Burn to Shine. Two subsequent albums "The Soundest Serum" (2007) and "Lucidia" (2012) followed.